New Analysis Challenges “Lopsided Universe” Claims: Study Identifies Systematic Instabilities in Quasar Dipole Measurements
For decades, the standard model of cosmology has assumed the universe is isotropic—the same in all directions—when viewed on the largest scales. However, recent high-profile studies utilizing the CatWISE quasar sample reported a dipole amplitude in number counts that significantly exceeded theoretical expectations, leading to claims that the universe might have a preferred direction.
Smith’s new research, currently available as a public preprint and data release, utilizes the unWISE time-domain catalogue to perform an epoch-sliced analysis spanning 2010 to 2020. The findings reveal that the measured dipole amplitude varies strongly over time. Because a true cosmological or kinematic dipole must remain time-invariant, this instability indicates that the signal is likely imprinted by time-dependent selection or coverage effects in the WISE satellite’s scanning pattern.
Key Findings of the Study:
- Axis Instability: While the dipole amplitude appears stable, the directional axis “drifts” significantly as the analysis includes fainter objects, moving from near-alignment with the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) to a 34° separation.
- CMB-Perpendicular Growth: This drift is driven by an increasing component perpendicular to the CMB, suggesting interference from data-completeness issues.
- Systematic Sensitivity: Injection and recovery tests demonstrate that even modest modulations in survey depth can bias both the recovered amplitude and the axis of the dipole.
- Statistical Outlier: A correlated-cut Monte Carlo analysis shows that the observed drift in the data lies in the < 1 per cent tail, making it highly unlikely to be a result of random fluctuations.
“The results motivate significant caution regarding cosmological interpretations of the CatWISE dipole,” says Smith. “Without an end-to-end completeness model that is validated in the time domain, we risk mistaking satellite scanning patterns for new laws of physics.”
The full manuscript, LaTeX source, and reproducibility materials have been archived on Zenodo to ensure complete transparency and allow for independent verification by the scientific community. The work is also available on a website Smith set up called “QuasarDipolePhenomenon.org“, where he also hosts other upcoming potentially groundbreaking studies including “A Calibrated Dark-Siren Tension with the General-Relativity Distance-Redshift Relation in GWTC-3.”
About the Researcher: Aiden Smith is an independent researcher focused on statistical methods in cosmology and large-scale structure. This study was conducted using publicly available data from the CatWISE2020 and unWISE Time-Domain catalogues.
Data and Reproducibility: Manuscript DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18530376 Supplementary Assets DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18489200
Press Release Distributed by PRLog
Source: Aiden Blake Smith
Follow the full story here: https://przen.com/pr/33605508
